Our Menu
Batter Up Bakery is known for our decadent cheesecakes - from timeless classics to fun new flavors, we have a wide-variety to choose from. View below for our list of current flavors.
*Please note: final decorated cheesecakes may vary from pictures below.
Batter Up Bakery Flavors
7 Layer
Indulge in layers of sweetened coconut, marshmallows, butterscotch chips, chocolate chips, and walnuts. [Graham Crust] *(GF)
Banana Cream
Rich, creamy, banana flavored cheesecake with a smooth and silky finish. [Graham Crust]
Blueberry Crumb
Bursting with Maine wild blueberries and topped with a buttery crumb layer for a perfect balance of flavor and texture. [Graham Crust]
Buncha Crunch
A nostalgic treat! Creamy cheesecake on an Oreo crust with Crunch baked in and topped with whip cream and Buncha Crunch pieces for the perfect bite. [Oreo Crust]
Caramello
Silky caramel-infused cheesecake on an Oreo crust for a melt-in-your-mouth experience. [Oreo Crust] *(GF)
Chocolate Cherry (Seasonal)
Chocolate cherry cheesecake blends creamy classic filling with sweet maraschino cherries baked in and topped with whip and shaved chocolate curls. [Oreo Crust] *GF
Chocolate Raspberry
Decadent chocolate cheesecake with bursts of tart raspberry flavor baked inside.
[Oreo Crust] *(GF)
Coconut Cream
A tropical delight with a creamy coconut flavored base and topped with toasted coconut. [Graham Crust] *(GF)
Coffee Crumb
Rich, creamy cheesecake infused with coffee flavor, topped with a buttery cinnamon crumb topping for the perfect sweet and crunchy bite! [Graham Crust]
Coffee Oreo
Bold coffee cheesecake with Oreo cookie crumbs blended in for a delightful texture and flavor combo. [Oreo Crust]
Coffee Toffee
Rich coffee cheesecake paired with sweet, crunchy toffee bits for an irresistible treat. [Oreo Crust] *(GF)
Confetti
Fun and festive, this cheesecake is speckled with colorful sprinkles for a sweet celebration in every bite. [Graham Crust] *(GF)
Cookie Butter
A velvety cheesecake infused with spiced cookie butter for a warm, indulgent treat. [Graham Crust]
Cookies & Cream
Classic cheesecake swirled with oreo cookie crumbs for a nostalgic and delicious dessert. [Oreo Crust]
Cookie Dough
Chunks of gooey, chocolatey cookie dough swirled into rich cheesecake for a decadent dessert. [Graham Crust]
Hawaiian (Seasonal)
Smooth coconut cheesecake with juicy pineapple baked in, topped with whipped cream and a cherry for a tropical touch. [Graham Crust] *GF
Key Lime (Seasonal)
Refreshing lime zest cheesecake with a bright, tangy flavor, topped with a swirl of whipped cream for the perfect finish. [Graham Crust] *GF
Lemon
Zesty, refreshing luscious lemon topped with whip. [Graham Crust] *(GF)
Lemon Blueberry
Bright, zesty lemon cheesecake with sweet bursts of Maine wild blueberries baked right in and topped with whip cream[Graham Crust] *(GF)
Lemon Raspberry
Tart lemon meets the tangy sweetness of raspberries for a refreshing twist. [Graham Crust] *(GF)
Maple Blueberry (Seasonal)
Maple blueberry cheesecake combines creamy maple-infused filling with sweet-tart blueberries, creating a delightful dessert with a perfect balance of rich, fruity, and warm flavors. [Graham Crust]
Maple Walnut (Seasonal)
Maple walnut cheesecake features a creamy, maple-infused filling topped with toasted walnuts, offering a delicious balance of sweet, nutty, and rich flavors [Graham Crust] *(GF)
Mint Chocolate
Creamy classic base with chopped Andes mints baked in then topped with chocolate ganache and more Andes mints on crunchy cookie crust. [Oreo crust] *GF
Mocha Chip
A mocha-infused cheesecake dotted with chocolate chips for the perfect coffee and chocolate pairing. [Oreo Crust] *(GF)
Peanut Butter Cup
Creamy peanut butter cheesecake topped with homemade ganache and peanut butter cups. [Oreo Crust] *(GF)
Pistachio
Smooth, nutty pistachio cheesecake topped with whip cream and chopped pistachios [Graham Crust]
Plain
A timeless classic: smooth, rich, and creamy cheesecake in its purest form on a graham crust. [Graham Crust] *(GF)
Rocky Road
A chocolate-based cheesecake on an Oreo crust, packed with marshmallows, chocolate chips, and sliced almonds. [Oreo Crust] *(GF)
Scotcheroo
Our rich peanut butter cheesecake baked with butterscotch chips and chocolate chips resembling the taste of the scotcheroo rice krispie treats of yesteryear. [Oreo crust] *GF
Snickers
Love Snickers? This rich cheesecake on a chocolate crust has chopped Snickers baked right in then topped with homemade ganache, caramel and more Snickers! [Oreo Crust] *(GF)
Strawberry Crunch
Luscious cheesecake with a strawberry crunchy crumble topping for a sweet, textured finish on a graham crust. [Graham Crust]
Toffee Salted Caramel
Velvety cheesecake with chopped Heath baked in then drizzled with salted caramel & homemade ganache for a sweet and salty delight. [Oreo Crust] *(GF)
Turtle
Decadent cheesecake topped with caramel, homemade chocolate ganache and roasted pecans for a classic “turtle” candy-inspired dessert. [Oreo Crust] *(GF)
Twix
Layers of creamy cheesecake and chopped Twix baked together then topped with caramel, homemade chocolate ganache and chunks of Twix bars for a candy bar lover’s dream. [Oreo Crust]
White Chocolate Raspberry
A swirl of tangy raspberry and creamy white chocolate in every bite of this luxurious cheesecake. [Graham Crust] *(GF)
Allergy Information
Gluten-Free Options: We offer gluten-free graham and gluten-free Oreo crusts. Flavors marked with *GF are available as gluten-free in the whole cheesecakes only. We are not a gluten free facility but do our best to limit cross contamination.
Allergy Warning: May Contain or come in contact with eggs, milk, dairy, wheat, soy, peanuts, nuts, tree nuts, dyes, gluten.


